When it comes to classic horror films, The Wolf Man (1941) stands as one of the crown jewels in Universal’s monster movie catalog. Lon Chaney Jr.’s portrayal of the tortured Larry Talbot, who transforms into a werewolf after being bitten, became iconic, shaping how we think of werewolves in cinema for decades.

Almost seven decades later, Benicio del Toro steps into the role for the 2010 remake, a film that pays homage to the original but amps up the horror. Now, with a new Wolf Man movie on the horizon, set for release in 2025, it’s the perfect time to look back at these two films and wonder what the future holds for this howling horror legend.

The original Wolf Man (1941)

The Wolf Man is the embodiment of Universal’s classic monster movie formula. The film focused heavily on themes of guilt, fate, and transformation. Larry Talbot is a sad character, cursed by forces outside his control. Unlike modern horror, where gore and shock tend to dominate, this film is all about building tension and creating a gothic mood.

The fog-covered forests and the haunting, almost poetic dialogue build an aura of inevitability around Larry’s fate. While the werewolf transformation scenes are primitive by today’s standards, they were groundbreaking for their time. Jack Pierce’s iconic makeup for the Wolf Man made Chaney Jr.’s transformation look more like a tragic curse than a monstrous outburst.

This film also focused heavily on character, something rare in today’s monster flick. Larry Talbot is not just a man running from a beast; he’s a man struggling with his identity and guilt. That kind of struggle added a lot to the story, making it more than just a horror movie.

Wolfman remake (2010)

Then came the 2010 remake, with Benicio del Toro as the Wolfman. The remake had a tough job—pay homage to the original while making it engaging for a modern audience. And, in many ways, it succeeded. Directed by Joe Johnston, this version leaned heavily into gothic horror, with stunning visual effects, including a terrifying werewolf transformation.

Del Toro’s take on the character was more brooding and introspective. His portrayal of Lawrence Talbot was someone deeply scarred by trauma, adding a darker, more psychological layer to the character. The 2010 film also ramped up the action, with some pretty intense werewolf-on-the-loose sequences, particularly during the infamous attack in London. This time around, the gore and violence were front and center, a nod to modern horror tastes.

However, despite the updated special effects and action sequences, The Wolfman (2010) stayed true to the central tragedy of the character. Lawrence is still a man doomed by a curse he can’t control, and that core theme—man versus monster within—was as powerful in 2010 as it was in 1941.

The upcoming Wolf Man (2025)

Now, we’ve got another Wolf Man on the way, this time helmed by Leigh Whannell (The Invisible Man) and starring Christopher Abbott and Julia Garner. The premise sounds intriguing, with the story focusing on a family in the Oregon wilderness as the father, Blake, begins to transform into a werewolf. The film promises a more isolated, psychological horror approach, with the family trapped inside a farmhouse during a terrifying werewolf attack.

Whannell has proven he knows how to take classic horror stories and reinvent them for modern audiences. His 2020 reboot of The Invisible Man was a hit, giving it a modern makeover while staying true to the psychological terror of the original. If Wolf Man (2025) can do the same, we might get something truly special. Instead of leaning into action and spectacle, it seems this film may focus more on character-driven horror, much like the original Wolf Man (1941).

Hopefully, Whannell’s version will add the gothic feel while injecting something new into the genre—just as the 2010 remake did with its visuals. Perhaps it will find that perfect balance between the suspense of the 1941 original and the visceral terror of the 2010 film. If it can, we could be looking at a worthy successor to the Wolfman legacy.

Let’s hope that when The Wolfman returns to the big screen in 2025, it captures the tragedy, horror, and dark beauty that have kept audiences hooked for decades.